Andrew's Opera was previously published at http://www.redfernclinic.com/

29 March, 2016

Sydney Harbour Turandot

Turandot - Puccini - Opera on Sydney Harbour Thurs 24 March 2016 7.30pm
 
Dear Colleagues,
 
For the fifth year in a row the opera company has put on an open-air extravaganza at Mrs Macquarie’s Chair, a narrow native peninsula which juts out into Sydney Harbour just east of the opera house and in full view of the entire city, sunset and subsequent stars (and full moon rise on cue at 7.30pm).  Even mini-golf could become interesting in such a setting (each to their own!).  Dining before the opera on the artificial parapet with the setting sun and harbour backdrop was all quite magical.  The food was excellent but would not be found in ‘Cheap-eats’. 
 
The pontoon ‘opera’ is not real opera because it is amplified.  However, one has to appreciate the spectacle, ambiance and ‘fun of the fair’.  And there was plenty of fun in this opening night event in addition to the opera.  I confess mixed feelings about the taking public foreshore property for this very elite purpose … and about the Hollywoodisation of opera.  The latter especially as we were in full view of the Opera House where fine opera still happens from time to time, regardless of the weather. 
 
On the Olympic sized pontoon stage was an enormous sculpted dragon’s head on the left with stylised body and tail across to the right behind a tall silver tower looking something like a monster Darlek from Doctor Who.  The latter was suitably fenestrated for appearances and descent of the Ice Princess and ascent of the lovers in the finale. 
 
The opera opens with a suspended Mandarin ‘town crier’ reminding the crowds of the ancient law regarding would-be suitors of Turandot.  Mr Dubinski sang like he always sings, somewhat less than perfect.  At times he did not even seem to sing the notes Puccini carefully chose for him.  David Lewis sang well as Emperor, appearing on a broad suspended chaise with the Writ of the Riddles as his painful duty for the beautiful princess’s betrothal. 
 
All of the other singers were also top-class.  As slave girl, Liu, the secondary soprano role can up-stage the title role and we were not disappointed with either.  The very expensive glossy souvenir program does not inform us who was actually singing since there were doubles for the major roles.  Because of early Easter the opera was performed on Thursday, Saturday, Sunday, Tuesday, etc, keeping us guessing about the principals’ identities.  As in the opera house, there should have been a cast list at the very least. 
 
Ping, Pang and Pong were perfectly cast as the chattering public servants.  John Longmuir, Benjamin Rasheed and Luke Gabbedy sang and acted their routines with style and flair.  And THEY are to sing EVERY night until 24th April according to the program (Mondays excluded). 
 
The chorus sang and acted brilliantly and I presume body microphones and careful mixing yielded the satisfying auditory production, balanced with the Neptunian orchestra under baton of underworld Maestro Brian Castles-Onion.  At least they got to parade centre-stage in the curtain calls. 
 
Careful trawling on the company’s web-site finds that opening-night Turandot was performed by Serbian super-soprano Dragana Radakovic, Liu by Hyeseoung Kwon and Calaf by Riccardo Massi.  They were all incomparable in my view.  This cast is to sing again on Sunday 27th and Tuesday 29th April.  Veteran Kiwi bass Conal Coad plays blind Timur, king without a kingdom. 
 
‘Nessun dorma’ is the great tenor showpiece everyone waits for and it did not disappoint, Mr Massi singing a fine aria and holding a long penultimate note to enormous ovation.  And then fireworks were released just in case anyone was still asleep (‘Nessun dorma’ means ‘no-one sleeps’).  After the clapping we had a reprise of several bars so the ‘through-written’ third act could continue.  Puccini never intended the final word, ‘vincero’ to be sung as it is now (the first person plural is one exception to the usual Italian rule of emphasis to be placed on the second last vowel). 
 
For these operas the company uses one intermission, thus pushing acts together with a few ‘cuts’.  Three short acts as Puccini wrote would allow more mingling, more food and another drink in two intermissions.  It would also allow the singers and orchestra two proper breaks in a very full evening. 
 
Tickets range from $70 to $330 with options for supper, drinks and glossy program.  There are no bad seats although I would advise avoiding the front 4 rows.  Take binoculars if you want to see the expressions on the singers’ faces. 
 
Written by Andrew Byrne ..
 
 
G.Rossini, Semiramide Overture (for 8 pianos)   https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8pdGIrOwy6s
 

15 February, 2016

Luisa Miller - Verdi - Sydney Opera House Thursday 11 Feb 2016

Dear Colleagues,

 
Luisa Miller in Sydney is vocally magnificent and is a MUST-SEE show for the season.  Get a ticket quickly as there are only seven performances in all.  This Verdi gem came just before Rigoletto - and it shows some of the same father - daughter interactions, combined with a parallel father - son relationship causing insoluble tensions only resolved by death (poisoning this time - and only after a lot of magnificent singing). 

 
Nicole Car has all that it takes for this taxing dramatic and vocal role.  I cannot understand why she appears in three negligees when everyone else is in 20th century attire.  The reason she has to spend so much time on the ground is that there are no props on stage apart from wire chairs, mostly on their sides.  The protagonists’ castles have no couches, no tables, no doors, windows, stairs or fireplaces … just bare black ramped stage.  No problem, we can imagine all of the above … but why then did we need to see an inane slow-motion roller-coaster during the overture, replete with chorus slowly encircling the stage with out-sized candles?  Luna Park did better 50 years ago.  Do they really think that we need something extraneous to keep us awake during what might be Verdi’s best overture?  Any activity on stage necessarily detracts from what the composer wanted and what his audience deserves. 

 
The same rote chorus manoeuvre happened during the opera’s most famous aria, partially obscuring Mr Torre as he sang ‘Quando le sere al placido’ to enormous and well deserved applause.  In this long tenor scene Mr Torre did not quite pace himself and ran short on voice just before the end - a small failing considering the feat … and for the final scenes the voice returned intact and full heft. 

 
One wonders if the artistic contributors actually like opera … they certainly don’t understand it from this outing to my mind.  And they seem to have collaborated with tobacco companies, and distractingly so.  The co-production from Lausanne originally planned to have the monochrome epoxy Tussaud’s domestic scene swung up 90 degrees around to be at the rear of the stage but in Sydney it ends up high above it.  It is so badly designed that (if it mattered) half the audience could not see a cream gentlemen and top-hat BEHIND the huge cream fire place, whatever significance that may have had.  But they do make fine watches in Switzerland. 

 
Luisa’s father is played by Slovak baritone Mr Dalibor Jenis who is possessed of a large and expressive voice and dramatic skills to boot.  We heard his Onegin two years ago and I hope we will be hearing more of him in the future, such is the rare beauty of his voice and his ability to nail an exciting high note when required. 

 
Almost uniquely, this opera calls for two basses, local Daniel Sumegi as ‘Wurm’ and American Raymond Aceto as Count Walter.  They both need to portray profound evil as each has dark secrets which are ably conveyed in the wonderful Verdi score.  Both sang with skill and conviction and their famous duet was stunning. 

 
The orchestra under Andrea Licata was responsive and tireless.  The solo clarinettist was not credited in the program hand-out despite being featured prominently in the opera, starting with the overture. 

 
Both Rigoletto and Luisa Miller contain vocal and dramatic experiments and it is self evident that the former were more successful than the latter.  Some of the vocal lines in Luisa Miller are more acrobatic than elegant with staccato and stepping progressions.  Yet we have a rare opera with an excellent cast in our distant opera world which is indeed a privilege and an opportunity for any opera lover.  Tickets from $44 to $300 nobody should miss out but it is selling fast. 

18 January, 2016

The Pearlfishers, Georges Bizet, at the Sydney Opera House.

Sydney Opera House - The Pearlfishers, Georges Bizet

Opening Friday 15th January 2016

This new production of The Pearlfishers is marvellous - but it is not novel. What is novel is to hear four superb voices and a large, schooled chorus on this stage. Guillaume Tourniaire also did a novel reading of the score, taking some early parts particularly slowly as well as some later chorus parts at a cracking pace.

Samuel Johnson’s definition of opera being exotic and irrational was certainly true of this odd interpretation where all three male Ceylonese protagonists are attired in European clothing. The chorus and extras wear pseudo native outfits or almost nothing at all. I make a point of never reading production notes as I don’t want to read excuses as to why the interpreters have ignored the libretto. The only thing new for me was the old Brahmin priest Nourabad being bribed successively, amusing and sadly ‘a point’ considering the sad position some in the clergy have found themselves in recent years (was it ever thus?). Otherwise this production had the essentials of temple, coastline, beach and ocean - but the representation of the sea looked more like blue tinsel gelato than any marine scene I’ve ever seen.

Young tenor Pavol Breslik from Bratislava was very fine, although not completely suited to Nadir which really requires that specialist French tenor style with upper extension. For the last strains of “Je crois entrendre encore” he simply stopped singing - a bizarre act but probably better than cracking on a high note (many a tenor has used falsetto here and I have heard at least one great tenor recording doing the same non-ending as here). [I have since learned that this was the way Bizet wrote the aria and the familiar high ending was interpolated by others.] We were told that Mr Breslik had sung Lensky (Onegin) and Edgardo (Lucia) on successive nights in Munich recently (as one does). I call it stupid.

But the star of the night was Leila played by beautiful Russian soprano Ekaterina Siurina. She performed flawlessly with a stage presence and forte singing plus all the extras … trills, extended breath control and amazing, strong high notes, all accurate and tasteful. Her ‘Comme autrefois’ was magnificent. She also received a strong and well deserved acclaim at the end. In contrast to the Russian singer’s meteoric CV, the management’s choice for second cast soprano is said to be “embarking on a promising and exciting operatic career” and this would appear to be her first role in an opera house. One wishes her luck but Ms Siurina will be a hard act to follow … and the show goes on for 15 performances over 2 months, most seats yet to sell according to the web site.

Zurga was played by Jose Carbo who was in big voice and drama, as we have come to expect. He was given a ludicrous long beard as well as a ridiculous wobbly woven crown yet his artistry shone through. Daniel Sumegi sang the rather thankless role of Nourabad with power and poise (even though he was made to look more like a gangster than a Brahmin priest).

Two questions arise: one why this opera is SO popular in Sydney and two, why it is so rarely performed elsewhere. It may be that an early radio broadcast by the ABC around 1965 “seeded” this opera for a generation of Australian opera lovers. We heard Pearlfishers all through the 1980s and 90s then in 2000, 2003, 2008 and 2012.

This month the Metropolitan Opera in New York breaks a century long drought for The Pearlfishers with a telecast production including Diana Damrau, Matthew Polenzani, and Mariusz Kwiecien. The last at the Met was with Caruso and DeLuca in 1916, in Italian. More Australians may see The Pearlfishers in the cinema than in the theatre as a result of this bad timing. It is hard to imagine a lot of opera fans desperate to hear this opera a second time so soon. And foreign visitors may just think the opera is a canard in the canon rather than the true operatic jewel that it is (IMO).

There seemed to be more music including an extra chorus and a glorious love-to-the-gallows duet just near the end which I don't recall ever hearing before. They may have been cut-down versions we heard in the past. There was no auto-da-fe this time I’m pleased to say, just some off-stage glints and hints of fire and brimstone. There was no second intermission in this outing and so with the two scenes in the third act we had two long and awkward pauses in the theatre. This will not suit everyone, most important, the composer wanted his singers to have a break, not to mention the orchestra, bar sales, audience DVT risk (economy class syndrome), etc. But it is a trade-mark of this management to compress their operas, ignoring the untold if unmeasured benefits of the operatic intermission (they have always been terrified of orchestra overtime payments). Some ticket-holders, I am told, only attend because of the intervals!

Altogether an excellent performance but in a long line of impressarial goofs on this company’s way to possible insolvency sad to say. According to a recent press article the company needed to borrow twice on the following year’s funding to pay the bills.

Notes by Andrew Byrne ..



I acknowledge the traditional owners and custodians of this land on which I walk and work, the Gadigal people of the Eora nation, and pay my respects to elders both past and present.

15 September, 2015

2016 Sydney opera season: Too little too late: the end of an era.

Dear Colleagues,
 
My first operas and operettas were at Rockdale dating from about 1960 … the attached was my first real opera subscription ticket … dating from ~1971 before the opening of the Sydney Opera House.  While a student at Sydney University I was a supernumerary ‘extra’ before I became the chorus dresser and then unofficial opera company doctor.  I seem to have had continuing tickets for over 40 years.  For many seasons I had two parallel subscriptions so I could see some operas twice - and shared these with a number of very notable Sydney personalities.  But this week, after careful consideration of the offerings for 2016, my renewal lapsed.  My expectations have been disappointed for quite some years but I lived in hope.  And indeed we have seen a few high quality operas in recent years … but they have been outnumbered by repeats, poor quality casts and endless musical comedy seasons.  I found that I was giving away more tickets than I was using. 
 
I recently attended a mid-season performance of the latest Marriage of Figaro and noted that it was well received as an original and well thought out production of this classic work.  Mr McVicar’s version of Cosi fan tutte next year may also be worth waiting for.  Luisa Miller and Simon Boccanegra are both rare and dark Verdi operas while Love of Three Oranges is a Prokofiev masterpiece.  But somehow I could not get excited about the other offerings for the new season.  I waited until after the renewal period before writing as I did not wish to influence anyone against supporting the opera company, or what remains of it. 
 
But three or four operas can hardly justify a full subscription series - the company once presented up to 16 operas per year from which subscribers could choose. 
 
While the new subscription brochure contains a couple of good prospects, for regular subscribers, repeats of La Boheme, Turandot, Pearlfishers, Carmen, Barber of Seville, My Fair Lady (no cast announced) and Magic Flute all yield a feeling of deja vu.  I just hope they can fill the houses with newcomers.  But for $300 per ticket it may be difficult.  The story about cruise passengers filling seats is mythology as nearly all liners are only in port from 6am to 6pm.  
 
We last heard The Marriage of Figaro in 2010 then again in 2015, not an unreasonable frequency for a popular classic.  However, some others are being dished out two years running! (eg. Turandot).  The 2016 Sydney season contains no Wagner.  There is no Trittico.  There is no international star important enough to put on the front cover.  There is now only a small group of top-class Australian artists (such as Daniel Sumegi, José Carbó, Emma Matthews, Lorina Gore, Nicole Car, Rosario LaSpina) most of whom still work overseas some of the time.
 
The final straw was news that Watkins’ fine Australian opera The Eighth Wonder is to be performed outside, on the steps of the opera house.  What are they thinking?  The opera is devoted to the story of an opera house yet they evacuate the place for the night!  I am not making this up! 
 
Like many other lapsed subscribers I will be buying individual seats to a couple of the operas in 2016 and hoping that there is some sort of meltdown in the management returns us to a rational and consistent approach to opera in this country.  If it can happen in Canberra, why not the national opera company?  In spite of this, I remain a patron and donate a modest modicum to the company hoping for change (and a few dress rehearsal tickets for my relations).
 
Written by Andrew Byrne ..

19 July, 2015

Don Carlos. Sydney Opera House. Tuesday 14th July 2015

Prince Don Carlos - Diego Torre
Rodrigo - José Carbó
Eboli - Milijana Nikolic
Elisabeth de Valois - Latonia Moore
King Philip II - Ferruccio Furlanetto
The Grand Inquisitor - Daniel Sumegi
Celestial voice - Julie Lea Goodwin
Conductor - Andrea Licata
 
What can one say about such a splendid and multifaceted performance of Verdi’s longest and blackest opera?  The voices were almost too much for this small theatre!  A lady sitting in the front stalls complained at interval that her ears hurt after the auto-da-fe scene!  With a title tenor so loud (and at times slightly ungainly) it was hard for the rest to keep a tasteful balance … but somehow it never left the rails to become the train wreck that could have resulted.  Diego Torre is an archetypical tenor, shorter and stouter than the average but with a huge and resonant voice.  This was one of the most high-tensile and exciting performances I have attended. 
 
The world-class bass Signore Furlanetto was true to his reputation, singing his long and tragic Act 4 monologue to perfection (below a Las Meninas inspired master).  We were also privileged to hear two excellent Australian basses in Daniel Sumegi as Grand Inquisitor and David Parkin as the crippled monk/Charles V. 
 
American soprano Ms Latonia Moore sang superlatively as Elisabetta whose big aria is tucked into the last act.  Tu, che le vanita conoscesti del mondo .. which was sung in full voice with clarity to boot.  Moore’s range is extraordinary with power in both high and low notes. 
 
Jose Carbo as Roderigo Marquis di Posa maintained his warm, velvet baritone and dramatic persona throughout this long part.  His Act I duet with the tenor was magnificent, as was his death scene.  I think he is the only fully likeable character in the opera.  Ms Nikolic started out below par and sounded muted at times.  With her high-brow fellow singers she rose to greatness on occasions yet her O don fatale was just passable (it is my favourite part of the whole opera). 
 
The conductor seemed to take some sections slightly faster than the singers might have liked … but clearly knew what he was doing in this dark and relentless piece. 
 
This old Moshinsky production has a couple of odd features but overall is very effective.  It is from an era when clunky scene changes were acceptable.  This four act version of a five act opera has been further truncated into two halves with a single intermission.  Verdi ordained these breaks for good reason … singers and musicians and audience all need a rest and it takes time to rebuild the stage.  In Act IV the king sings of the candles burning down yet there were no candles on stage.  Eboli traditionally glimpses Carlo's death warrant on the king’s table, yet there is only a pile of books so Eboli has to respond as if she had just learned of the plans and sings the last exciting notes of the act.  No matter … most of the details were included - and more - in this production. 
 
The audience was enthusiastic yet there were hundreds of empty seats for this opening night.  ‘Natural selection’ saw many of Sydney’s opera aficionados attending, drawn by the rarely performed opera and/or the big names performing it.  Many previous subscribers deserted the company so opening nights are no longer the sold-out sessions they were.  The management has been derogatory about subscribers, pushing to serve some other audience which seems not to exist.  Supposed sales to cruise passengers is mythology since most liners arrive at dawn and leave at dusk, leaving no time for evening opera.  It is a small miracle that we still have an ‘opera’ company at all in Sydney. 
 
Notes by Andrew Byrne ..

13 July, 2015

Subject line: “Whelming” La Traviata.


La Traviata - Sydney Opera House Friday 3rd July 2015
Violetta - Lorina Gore
Alfredo - Rame Lahaj
Germont senior - José Carbó
Cond: Renato Palumbo

 
On going through my opera notes I found 14 reviews of this opera in as many years.  Some were cast changes and some were in New York.  One was on Sydney Harbour.  I was not looking forward to yet another Traviata, especially in a production I had seen many times.  The performance was underwhelming and I had decided not to write notes until I spoke to an old hand who pointed out that some of the singers just seemed to be mouthing the words and notes without knowing the drama and its sentiments.  This applies especially to the tenor but also to the other roles to some extent.  Indeed they sang all of the notes, even some unwritten ones.  While comparisons are odorous, having heard Kiri Te Kanawa, Joan Sutherland, Regina Schorg, Joan Carden and other greats as Violetta in this same hall it is hard to say that Ms Gore is yet ready despite her marvelous talents. 

 
Apart from the mid-level ‘loges’, the hall was almost full … but I noted a number of people who appeared to be on complimentary tickets … and some couples who also received free entries to the patrons’ lounge.  Each of these potentially deprived the company of about $700 which in a normal company could be liable to Fringe Benefits Tax. 

 
If it was your first, this opera performance might have been satisfactory yet for seasoned opera goers it was pedestrian.  And the young singers are being pushed to do three performances of this enormous work each week, something I find criminal.  I note that Turandot and Don Carlos with serious international casts are only being put on twice each week in their current seasons in Sydney.  Grand opera is like marathon running and only the foolhardy, needy or greedy would deny performers adequate recovery time.  Furthermore, the highly regarded baritone José Carbó is apparently being cast to sing Germont and Roderigo on successive nights!!  This is a recipe for vocal disaster and implicates the company management in doing the opposite of what they are charged to do by their own charter, The Australia Council, good sense and tradition. 
  I say no more … but look forward to Don Carlos on Tuesday. 

 Notes by Andrew Byrne ..
 
 

 

28 June, 2015

Big voices make for terrific Turandot at Sydney Opera House.

Turandot - Wed 24th June 2015 - Sydney Opera House.
 
Fasten your seat belts as this is one exciting escapade to open the Sydney opera season.  This Turandot is a must-see and must-hear for anyone interested in great singing.  Seats are $44 (restricted view) to $300.  Finally the management seems to have worked out that opera is an international ‘sport’ and the principal roles need to be taken by serious international competitors. 
 
American dramatic soprano Lise Lindstrom sings the cold princess with a palpable presence.  She has an enormous, accurate and steely voice while also looking beautiful and acting well on stage. 
 
Mr Yonghoon Lee has a very large and well schooled voice with a pleasant and more-ish quality.  From Calaf’s first utterances he commands attention, even above the entire orchestra and chorus.  Mr Lee’s recent Don Carlos at the Met sounded very fine but to hear the same voice in a smaller theatre was extraordinary.  He is tall and cuts a decent figure on stage.  He received one of the few spontaneous standing ovations I have seen from a Sydney audience.  It was reminiscent of the Sutherland days of the 1980s.  And this was repeated for the soprano, and deservedly so. 
 
Hyeseoung Kwon sang Liu with the delicate legato needed for this important role. 
 
Civil servants Ping, Pang and Pong were sung brilliantly by Luke Gabbedy, Graeme Macfarlane and John Longmuir.  Jud Arthur was excellent as Timur, Calaf’s father.  The Mandarin or town crier should have a booming declamatory voice to open the opera and tell its story line.  Gennadi Dubinsky was disappointing and I wonder that the company uses him year after year for inappropriate roles.  The Emperor is a comprimario part and while tradition has him old and frail Mr Rasheed was either not up to singing the low notes or he was over-acting.  Yet these small deficiencies stand in stark contrast to the magnificent flow of glorious vocalising the likes of which we have not heard for some time in Sydney. 
 
The orchestra and chorus deserve full credit for recreating Graham Murphy’s vibrant production of Puccini’s last masterpiece (completed by his student Alfano).  The original choreography uses many modern tricks with ribbons, blackened mannequins, giant flags, fans and more.  Christian Badea conducted with accurate deference to the composer. 
 
A high point for me is the riddle scene in act II when, after moments of uncertainty, Calaf gives correct one-word responses to three riddles posed by the princess.  Like clouds parting after a storm the whole of Peking, except the princess, seems to lurch into major-key happiness.  Then the prince allows one additional riddle which, if answered correctly, would release the reluctant princess from her vow.  This in turn leads to the start of Act III and ‘Nessun dorma’ when ‘none shall sleep’ until the name of the mystery suitor is discovered.  After witnessing Liu’s descent into love-torn suicide, Turandot publicly claims to know the name, announcing it to be … “Amore” (love), averting a potential tragedy and allowing a happy ending with a full choral reprise of the ‘Nessun dorma’ or ‘World Cup’ theme. 
 
Just get a ticket! 
 
Written by Andrew Byrne ..
 
 
 
Clinic web page: http://methadone-research.blogspot.com/

01 May, 2015

Masked Ball at the Met - April 2015

Ballo in Maschera.  Met Opera NYC.  Thursday 23rd April 2015
 
This was one of the best opera performances I have seen in a long time.  A dream cast was combined with James Levine and his marvellous orchestra and chorus in a modern, clever and eclectic production by David Alden utilising 20th century décor and costumes with a mock-Tiepolo sky-scape of winged angel and four-horse chariot on high.  While a long way from the iconic traditional Met production, the 20th century update seems to work (at least second time around for me). 
 
Piotr Beczala (King), Dmitry Hvorostovsky (Renato), Sondra Radvanovsky (Amelia), Dolora Zajick (Ulrica) and Heidi Stober (Oscar).  Every one of these artists was superlative and deserving of a paragraph on detail.  Mr Hvorostovsky’s talents are well known and he was true to his reputation, often singing two lines on the one breath, hitting baritonal high notes with more ease than some tenors and acting the metamorphosis from the king’s friend to foe with stunning drama.  Ms Radvanovsky has the most ‘projected’ voice I have heard in a long while, yet she also uses subtlety and diminuendos with style and flare.  Mr Beczala is one of the best tenors in the world today.  His youthful good looks and dramatic talents combine with his vocal confidence at the high registers used frequently in Ballo.  He sings without forcing and often smiles during his delivery. 
 
Popular American mezzo-soprano Dolora Zajick was a splendid fortune teller, taking command of the entire space during her scene.  She even produces a skull from her leather handbag, a theme which is repeated with the skull masks of the conspirators in the last act.  We also see palm reading, playing cards and blank pages torn off writing pads by innominate public servants or scribes at innominate desks with innominate expressions and stylised movements.  The king’s court has formal waiters, soldiers, policy analysts, lobbyists, etc amongst the chorus as well as some dancers providing lots of movement on stage.  And conspirators, of course. 
 
The essence of the opera is that the king mocks prophecies of doom, saying the love of his people and God will protect him.  If this happened we would not have much of an opera!  Ulrica’s fortune-telling cards say that fate alone will decided events and humans are powerless to stop it with our frailties. 
 
Heidi Stober was a perfect Oscar in a white suit, sometimes winged, suitably spunky in a unisex way.  Like her colleagues, the voice soared into the auditorium on the numerous occasions required by the score.  His relationship with the king gives a gay side to the character and the death scene is played as such. 
 
Commentaries from some quarters recently complain that the Met is playing Verdi with poor quality casts and this in turn has led to poor attendances.  I find this hard to justify and would report exactly the opposite.  Poor attendances have occurred  in opera seasons around the world in recent years and the causes are complex.  This Friday opening seemed to have few empty seats.  During April several performances of Aida (conducted by Domingo) were virtually full as was Ernani (with Domingo playing the baritone role), leaving Don Carlos playing to less than full houses, probably due to the nature of the opera rather than the cast (which included Frittoli, Hvorostovsky, Furlanetto, Morris with Yonghoon Lee an excellent tenor in the title role).  Sadly sickness and substitution supervened on several occasions, notably when Michael Fabiano as Edgardo was brought into Lucia from Philadelphia at a few hours notice.  His single performance without rehearsal received a major accolade from the New York Times. 
 
The standard of operas at the Met remains very high from my experience … but I cannot say the same for operettas.  The Merry Widow was a disappointment and just did not seem to come to life as it can with the right chemistry.  The text was a very poor alternative translation and at times the performers just did not seem to want to be there.  The voices seemed under powered and amplification was inadequate to understand the dialogue without reading the subtitles which was not well synchronised anyway.  The Met should probably stick to opera! 
 
Notes by Andrew Byrne ..
 
Postcard from New York: http://ajbtravels.blogspot.com/

26 April, 2015

Cavalleria Rusticana (Mascagni) and I Pagliacci (Leoncavallo) at the Met April 2015

 
This dual production of the verismo twins is a strange marriage of directorial talent with megalomania … with much excellent singing shining through.  The McVicar productions will be controversial which probably suits The Met despite any insult to the art.  And the second opera IS an insult - from start to finish.  Pagliacci is a masterpiece, the composer himself a poet, carefully writing each line of the libretto in the marvellous drama which moves relentlessly towards theatrical tragedy by way of a play within a play.  The play itself has some ‘Punchinello’ slapstick yet the director expands this to the entire opera starting unforgivably half way through the Prologue, ‘Si puo?’ a baritone showpiece for good reason. 
 
In the busy and cluttered production of Pagliacci there are dozens of examples of hilarious and well rehearsed side-shows by acrobats, actors and vaudevillians.  Much of this distracts and thus detracts from what is happening centre-stage in the vocal drama we paid to see and hear.  The above example yields laughter from the audience during the Prologue over some shenanigans with a microphone cord stuck in Tonio’s groin, pulling three goofy assistants out of the wings, all to great hilarity.  The words of the Prologue compare life in the theatre with the real world and that the actors real and vulnerable people.  The ‘three stoogers’ are brilliant vaudeville actors, yet they are greatly overused to my mind. 
 
Another example is ‘clever’ but distracting, being Taddeo (Tonio’s) sudden appearance providing an alibi to Pagliaccio (Canio) for Colombina (Nedda) having set two places at table.  Traditionally this is sung as a terrified stammer ‘credetela’ (‘believe her!’) but McVicar has Tonio sing from the deep freeze cabinet as if he were shivering - ice and vapour for added realism as the door is opened to reveal the hidden witness.  The humour spoils the lines to my mind and does nothing but draw attention to Mr McVicar and away from Leoncavallo’s drama. 
 
Half way through Canio’s famous aria ‘Vesti la giubba’ the curtain mysteriously drops, breaking the continuity to some extent.  Mr Alvarez then continues the aria while stage noise can be heard behind, yet again distracting from what should be a magnificent set piece for the tenor.  Another unforgivable concession to stage pragmatism by Mr McVicar who is starting to get on my nerves. 
 
The noise of a truck’s starter-motor, especially a faulty one, is an ugly and unnecessary start to an opera, despite it being novel, funny and unexpected.  It is witless. 
 
Taddeo arrives in the play with a toy chicken (as required in the libretto - all of McVicar’s devices, however stupid, seem to come from the book) but he then uses the puppet as a TV character ventriloquist.  Nedda pokes the same springy toy into a saucepan and puts it on the stove as the attendant ‘three stoogers’ clown with a bowl of whipped cream which ends up on several faces.  Even the cooked chicken comes to life again on the dinner table - but does this hilarious gag add? 
 
Modern Met productions really require two reviews, one for the opera in the theatre and another for Live-HD cinema broadcast as they are significantly different experiences.  I can only comment on the theater experience after attending the twin operas (twice) live. 
 
To state the obvious, only the theatre audience will hear the actual live voices of the singers and direct orchestral sound unaltered by technology.  Thus voice size is less relevant to the cinema audience.  Likewise the appearance of revolving scenery and also mishaps … I was told that with a very short delay the live transmission can be switched to the previously recorded ‘rehearsal’ as a back-up in case of stage or technical problems.  I was not told how often this is done in practice but it would seem like a useful strategy to avoid disappointing a huge paying audience around the world (only countries near Australia’s longitude do NOT receive the broadcasts direct due to the inclement hour of night). 
 
Like the Lepage Ring, these operas, with all their faults, fulfil the Met's need for something completely different yet maintaining the realism demanded by a conservative New York audience.  On the same open, dark-walled set, the operas make a stark contrast from each other. 
 
Unlike the bright and busy Paglicci production, the first opera Cavalleria Rusticana is mostly dark and tranquil with the intense emotion depending on the musical/vocal components.  It commences with a huge ring of black chairs and a tasteful slow circuit of the stage revolve finds us virtually meeting each villager … a very Southern Italian thing to do.  Then very soon, like a child with a new toy, the director over-uses the stage revolve to the extent that I was positively vertiginous by the end of Pagliacci from the never-ending stage circles, both ways, fast and slow, most to no particularly dramatic point.  Most ridiculous was to see the entire chorus of over fifty singers in the first opera all gradually jerk themselves one way while the stage revolve goes the other, leaving them all in the same positions.  As a final insult just as the dramatic ‘La comedia e finita’ was announced the revolve went into full speed.  Presumably this was to present the empty side of the stage for the curtain calls … yet this could have been achieved without interrupting the opera’s dramatic ending.  I was intrigued that amid all the realistic attributes, candles, veils, wine jugs, fruit and vegetables, etc in Cavalleria Rusticana there was an odd mechanical refectory table with visible hydraulic expandable supports yet also with chunky wooden false legs.  One allows artistic licence but the one day of the year when village markets in Italy probably did not function was Easter Day. 
 
To give credit where it is due, the performance of Cavalleria Rusticana was both menacing and meaningful.  The singing was excellent … from the off-stage Siciliana to the shriek at the end announcing the death of Turridu.  Mr Alvarez played both tenor roles brilliantly while George Gagnidze played both Tonio and Alfio with equal effect.  Patricia Racette played Nedda both excellent in voice and as a sexy singing actress.  Santuzza was played solidly by Eva-Maria Westbroek.  Lola with the unlikely name of Ginger Costa-Jackson was born in Sicily and may have been the only cast member with genetic and cultural connections to the stories.  The minor roles were also all well acquitted.  Silvio (Lucas Meachem) and Nedda had a long section of their duet restored … and charmingly sung by both. 
 
By the modern vogue, ‘things’ happen on stage during each of the orchestral interludes … except for the Pagliacci intermezzo which then paradoxically is followed by a long pause, presumably for set changes.  The Intermezzo from Cavalleria Rusticana is one of the greatest operatic orchestral pieces ever written.  How bizarre then that a director would feel the need to deflect attention from it.  Would he put some stage miscellany on stage during a Beethoven symphony or Bach cantata?  Maybe he would!